Showing posts with label teacher dismissal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teacher dismissal. Show all posts

Monday, October 29, 2007

SBOE agenda for November

Just bumped into this link at the State of Tennessee's Education Department website. Back in August the State Board of Education approved a new set of science standards for K-8th grade. It's public comment time. The deadline on the web page is 'November' so you might want to read through those and comment very soon as it'll be taken up during their quarterly meeting on Friday, November, 2nd, in Legislative Plaza, Room 12, beginning at 8:30 a.m. Here's the agenda.

Also on the agenda, among other things, are 9-12 science curriculum standards (1st reading) rules for diversified pay plans, updated school bus specifications, and specific learning disability standards.

Oh, and 7 teachers may have their licenses pulled. Nancy Brown-Gearheiser may have her's reinstated. It was revoked in April of 2006 and the SBOE's minutes make no mention of why. In fact, the agenda doesn't provide any information about why the license status of any of these teachers is being changed. I think some comment would be in order.

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Thursday 12/14/06

Life is keeping me pretty busy. I'll make some quick comments on the following.

MNPS Chief Instructional Officer Sandra Johnson is, frankly, not well liked by many of our public education consumers. News in this morning's City Paper that she's up for a job anywhere else will be welcome.

Currently, Johnson oversees nearly all departments for the school district, answering only to Garcia.
And that's part of the problem for many parents. She wasn't accountable to the board and an obvious favorite of Garcia. If Glendale, Arizona wants her--God bless 'em.
“I think she’s done an admirable job and I certainly think it would be a loss to the district,” Thompson said. “And it may well be she has trained others enough to carry on.”
"Admirable?"--so there's one man's opinion. George is up for reelection in 2008. Let's see what tune he sings then.

LEAD Academy gets approval from the BOE. I'm very glad to see us get another charter school. This is an important option for some very needy students. MNPS isn't meeting their needs with what they have available--there is no good reason to keep there where they're not learning.
“A large part of the Pearl-Cohn district is in the district I serve,” [BOE member George] Thompson said. “My concern is how will we deal with maintaining Pearl-Cohn in the public school system if we’re going to help to populate a competing charter for that same population.”
Ask Sandra Johnson, George, she's been doing an 'admirable' job.

Actually, Mr. Thompson, the needs of the students should take precedence over saving any system. These students are not getting the education their parents were promised. We've got to try a different system. Regardless the board will protect the system despite the cost to students:
The board agreed to add language into LEAD’s contract to clarify the issue and guarantee the school would not drain the Pearl-Cohn cluster.
Pearl-Cohn cluster parents should contact the BOE members now and let them know how they feel about being excluded from a charter school that may very well be the answer to their child's education needs.

Traditional v. Balanced: Thank goodness the BOE members (well 7 at least) understood that a change was merely window dressing. That change for changes sake (a hallmark of public education) isn't beneficial for the children. Lacking any reliable evidence that the change will benefit the children and families the system serves it was given a thumbs down by the BOE.
“I hope tonight… that we don’t adopt policy simply to make a change and that we finally and permanently dump the balanced calendar matter into the dustbin of school board history,” Fox said. City Paper
Thank you, Mr. Fox. And for some illuminating information you may want to cruise over to the comments section of the Tennessean's article where "Magoo" posted the scores of local systems by calendar and it clearly shows that traditional scores higher. In our impatience and love for flash, glamour and NEW! we too easily abandon the boring and traditional forgetting that one of the reasons most traditions hang around is because they work. Sorry guys but it may be boring--but I'll take boring and effective over flashy and iffy every day when it comes to the essential education of our children.

Now maybe we can move that calendar all the way back to traditional and start after Labor Day and save some AC costs.

Cell phones for students--just not board members. This article in the City Paper Monday made me snort-laugh. After all the fuss the BOE went through over their cell phone use, the return of the phones, the vote over what equipment we could and couldn't have provided we now have MNPS handing out free phones to students.
The students have been allotted 500 minutes a month and all incoming calls are free of charge. Students are also encouraged to give out their cell phone numbers to fellow students to get feedback regarding district issues.
And what do we know about teens and allotted minutes? Let's see if teens are better than BOE members at limiting their minutes.

Irony aside, if this 'narc-phone network' works I'll be happy to pay the bill.

The Robert Bowers dismissal hearing continues according to yesterday's City Paper. It's these sorts of hearing that are exceptionally draining on BOE members. And it's these hearings that prove to me that the MNEA (Metro Nashville Education Association) is a union and not a professional organization. Yes, everyone deserves their day in court, but if MNEA were a true professional organization they'd be equally appalled that the unprofessionalism of some of their members and do some housekeeping of their own. Instead, if my summer dismissal experience and this current one are reliable indicators, they make excuses for the employee and point accusatory fingers at others in a desperate attempts to keep the employee employed--at the expense of children.
Bowers’ attorney Vince Wyatt implied during questioning of Mansfield that most of the errors were the fault of previous guidance counselors, not Bowers.
Then why wasn't Bower's complaining from the get go about the mess he'd inherited and why wasn't he begging for additional help?

It's time to work on the budget and so it's time to lead and stand. It doesn't look like Steve Glover understands that.
“I’m nervous about stepping out saying we’re going to cut this position or we’re going to cut these positions,” Glover said. “We’re really just so early in the game.” City Paper
Someone's got to start the process. I dearly hope there is a leader on that Board that will. Looks like Mr. Fox has taken over former BOE member Kathy Nevill's number crunching job for the BOE. Bless him and his calculator.

That's it for now, life calls.

Monday, October 30, 2006

It doesn't matter

This quote from Metro Nashville Public School Boards Chairman Marsha Warden is in today's Tennessean:

Marsha Warden, school board chairwoman, said its operations were transparent and would continue to be. However, the board is looking to be more sensitive to personal issues for employees and parents, she said.

"In no way, we intended to limit anyone's access to the performance of the district, and certainly the director's evaluation is a direct measurement of how we are doing as a district," Warden said. "I just don't know how many people have their personnel evaluation publicly scrutinized."

It doesn't matter how many of us have this sort of scrutiny. The fact is Pedro Garcia (and others) took the job knowing we had these minimal sunshine laws in this state and their personnel information would be and should be public record. If they objected to the 'scrutiny' they should not have taken the job.

The only people I'm concerned about is the children who are witnesses to the conduct of their teachers and the staff. I hate having them in the witness chair with all those adults surrounding them asking them over and over what happened, did that really happen, are you sure? But it's for their sake that we've got to ensure this process is as open as possible so that we know what to look for and who to be looking at. For their sake--accountability, full and legitimate accountably--does matter and is worth fighting for.

Saturday, September 09, 2006

MNPS BOE agenda for 9/12/06

I keep hoping that the agenda's will be posted to the Metro Nashville Public Schools website on the Thursday/Friday they're sent out to the Board members but not yet. I have been placed on the mailing list to get a complete copy of the agenda. I got it today in the mail and that's where I've copied this from. As I get time in the next couple of days I'll share more details. There is a lot of information from Dr. Pedro Garcia (Director of Schools) regarding grades and attendance. Also the contract with KIPP Academy the E. Nashville charter school

Immediate highlights:

New board officers will be sworn in. My understanding is that Ms. Garrett's 3 terms as chair will not be followed up with a 4th.

Dr. Garcia is asking to remove another teacher, Richard Bowers formerly of Maplewood High School. This is the third teacher in 2006 that is being so charged. All three have been from District 5. The charges look like they are part of the guidance counseling debacle that created such havoc in student records and lives at Maplewood.

Also included is a mysterious Legal Settlement Claim #C-16452 for $15,755. No other information is provided in the 117 page agenda packet. Further, it's under the consent agenda where it's unlikely it will be discussed or explained. That's $15K that we ought to know about.

The Committee to Evaluate the Director (Dr. Garcia) meets just before the board does at 3:45 p.m. in the Board Conference Room and will present to the entire Board later.

TIME










PAGE
5:00 I. CONVENE








A Establish Quorum







B. Pledge of Allegiance







C. Recognition of Audience Guests






D. Student Showcase - Vanderbilt Summer Internship Program



E. Student Board Members' Report


GP-3.1













5:30 II. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS


GP-3


A. Hattie Cotton PTO







B. Cami Townsel - 206 Tennessee Association of School Librarians'




Innovative Library Program Award





C. Recognition of Newly Appointed Administrators















5:55 III. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION


GP-3.1



We will now hear from those persons who have requested to appear at this Board



meeting. For expediency reasons, speakers are requested to limit remarks to three



minutes or less. Comments will be timed.





A. Molly Sudderth, Celebrate Nashville


1













6:00 IV. GOVERNANCE ISSUES







A. Actions










1 Approve Agenda


GP-2.2



2 Election of Board Officers


GP-3.9



3 Consent




GP-8.3




a. Approval of Minutes - 8/22/06 Regular Meeting

2




b. Change Order #2 - Brick Church Middle School Football Field 5





Improvements - Competition Athletic Construction - M-351





c. Change Order #2 - Eakin Elementary School

5




d. Legal Settlement Claim - C-16452


5




e. Request for Approval of Extended Contract Program Proposal for





2006-2007




5




f. Contract for KIPP Academy


10




g. Awarding of Bids and Contracts








1 Project for Neighborhood Aftercare

27





2 Learning Forum Educational Systems d/b/a Quantum







Learning/Supercamp


28





3 Scriba Education Services


29



3 Charges of Dismissal - Richard Bowers


30



4 Monitoring Reports - Administrative Presentation






a. EE-1 - Global Executive constraint


37




b. EE-2 - Emergency Succession


44




c. EE-15 - Learning Environment/Discipline

47




d. EE-2.1 - Academic Achievement - TCAP

79




e. E-23 - Academic Achievement - Gateway

99




f. E-2.5 - Academic Achievement - Advanced Placement/IB
106


B. Discussion









1 Graduation Rate


















7:00 V. REPORTS









A. Director's Report



EE-10




Magnet School Enrollment








Changes in Procedures for Graduation Ceremonies




B. Board Chairman's Report


GP-5




Director Evaluation Committee Report







Diversified Pay Committee

















7:45 VI. ANNOUNCEMENTS



GP-2.6













7:55 VII. WRITTEN INFORMATION FOR THE BOARD (not for discussion)



A. Board Calendar Items






B. Legislation Around the Natioin

















8:00 VIII. ADJOURNMENT/BOARD MEMBER EVALUATION
GP-2.6

Thursday, July 06, 2006

We dismissed a teacher

At about 2:00 a.m. this morning the Metro Nashville School Board dismissed a tenured teacher by a vote of 6 to 1. The teacher was charged by the administration in March of this year with incompetence, insubordination, neglect of duties and conduct unbecoming a member of the teaching profession--all as outlined in TCA 49-5-501. The BOE members upheld each of those charges and finally voted that dismissal was appropriate.

Dr. Mebenin Awipi abstained on the conduct unbecoming charge and voted no on the insubordination charge but did vote to dismiss.

Mr. Ed Kendall abstained on the neglect of duty charge and no on all the others including the vote to dismiss. He even moved that we dismiss the charges which failed for lack of a second.

The other BOE members voting yes on all charges and for the dismissal were: myself, George Blue, Pam Garrett, Kathy Nevill, and Marsha Warden.

It was an unpleasant task for everyone. It involved the lives of children, parents, co-workers, attorneys, union representatives, administrators, and eventually 7 members of the BOE and their staff. We heard nearly 30 39 hours of testimony that went long into the nights and reviewed a two inch stack of exhibits dating from October of 2002 involving two different principals in two different schools and several other education professionals that had interacted with this teacher.

For my part I found it impossible to review some of the lengthier exhibits and give proper attention to testimony at the same time and so at the end of the first session asked to take the stack of exhibits home. This request broke tradition but was allowed and I discovered that one page of a letter from the teacher had been left out. It was provided the next evening. It turned out to not be vital but, for the teacher's sake, I believe a complete record is important.

The teacher was given extreme latitude in presenting their testimony. Often their comments went far afield and frequently included unsubstantiated charges and conclusions about the conduct of others and those were rarely challenged. I'm convinced that they had every opportunity to have their full say in their defense.

What I would love to have had available and what wasn't provided by the teacher, were the Value Added scores for the classes. THAT, in my opinion, would have been a clear demonstration of their teaching effectiveness. But it wasn't offered. However, the testimony and exhibits showed a clear pattern of behavior that could not continue even with the best Value Added scores.

Kudos to the board, the staff and those tireless court reporters, they all acted with serious concern for the rights of the teacher while keeping the welfare of the children foremost in their minds.

All in all it shouldn't take four years, some 30 hours times 15 immediate participants, who knows how much other time and money in trying to handle the situation over four years' time and then preparing the case in order to remove a teacher. We've got to be able to more efficiently learn which employees just don't fit the job and encourage them on to better career paths.

I do hope this teacher finds a better path for their talents and skills that turns this very difficult time into the beginning of a much better season of their life.